Attack or Defense value/FS - Unit's Attack or Total Defense (sum of 3 types of defense) value divided by Farm Space (population used to build the unit). There are 2 values here:
-Land attack/support - when you attack on the same island, so you do not use ships for transport.
-Sea attack/support - when you attack somebody on a different island, so costs of transport ships were included (all values include cost of Fast Transport Ships with bunks).
As with the previous criteria, there are 2 values here: Land (excl. ships) and Sea (incl. ships), both explained above.
Offensive Units
Building an offensive army is easier than building a defensive one. While a defense has to be balanced against all types of attack, offense is most effective when it is made of only one type. Therefore we will need to consider three types of attacking armies: blunt, sharp and ranged.
Which one to produce, you ask? You can base your decision on the data you have acquired (i.e. spy reports) or just attack blind and hope for luck. If you have spy reports available use my calculator and it will suggest you the most effective unit to use against that particular defense. However, unless your enemy prepares his defenses purely against range attack, the best unit is Slinger - quick and cheap to produce. It is a perfect unit when you have to attack unknown enemy blind.
If you would like to learn more attacking then please see my other guide which you can find here.
Slingers
Type of attack: Range
Attack/FS: 17.5 (by Sea) or 23 (by Land)
Cost/Attack: 12.3 (by Sea) or 8.5 (by Land)
Slingers are kings of attacking forces among regular (non-Mythical). They are cheap and
fast in construction. Also their cost is very balanced - you do need more stone
than wood or silver but they require all three types of resources, so costs are
more or less spread out.
Slingers are units that have the highest attack value per FS and provide the cheapest attack among regular (non-mythical) units - they are also the most
effective and efficient Range attack units in the game including mythical units. In most
cases Slingers can provide the highest damage unless a defender has proportionally more range defense than any other type.
Slingers are countered very effectively by Swordsmen or Cerberus. It is really important to note: even if a player builds Swordsmen, he most likely does only to maintain a balanced defense. What it means is that attacking with Slingers will at least be as effective as with any other unit and in most cases more efficient (low costs). In theory it is easier and cheaper to build Swordsmen than for example Hoplites (which provide good Blunt defense against Horsemen) but people usually do not build enough of range defense.
Remember though, only because they are the strongest regular units and the cheapest ones that doesn't mean they are always the most effective or efficient force to use - it depends on the enemy defense composition. If a player totally neglects use of sharp defense, like Archers, then I send sharp attack units (like Hoplites or Manticores) but its rarity. You can read more about battle mechanics here.
Slingers are countered very effectively by Swordsmen or Cerberus. It is really important to note: even if a player builds Swordsmen, he most likely does only to maintain a balanced defense. What it means is that attacking with Slingers will at least be as effective as with any other unit and in most cases more efficient (low costs). In theory it is easier and cheaper to build Swordsmen than for example Hoplites (which provide good Blunt defense against Horsemen) but people usually do not build enough of range defense.
Remember though, only because they are the strongest regular units and the cheapest ones that doesn't mean they are always the most effective or efficient force to use - it depends on the enemy defense composition. If a player totally neglects use of sharp defense, like Archers, then I send sharp attack units (like Hoplites or Manticores) but its rarity. You can read more about battle mechanics here.
Slingers are also accessible very early in the game. The only problem with them is that they won’t be able to do much farming.
In the advanced stage of the game with 15+ cities I
usually had most of my cities producing Slinger nukes and 1 sharp nuke
(excluding my CS forces). You can have quick nukes or slow nukes. Here you will find more information regarding Slinger nuke.
Based on this, it may be a good idea to go for Slingers attack, if you know nothing about your opponent’s defense. Unfortunately, there are no flying mythical units to complement ranged offensive army, unlike the blunt and sharp cases. Erinyes, Cyclops and Centaurs are mythical ranged attackers but since they have worse parameters than Slingers both in terms of effectiveness (attack/FS) and efficiency (resource cost) – and they also consume favor – there is not much point in building them purely for attacking.
Based on this, it may be a good idea to go for Slingers attack, if you know nothing about your opponent’s defense. Unfortunately, there are no flying mythical units to complement ranged offensive army, unlike the blunt and sharp cases. Erinyes, Cyclops and Centaurs are mythical ranged attackers but since they have worse parameters than Slingers both in terms of effectiveness (attack/FS) and efficiency (resource cost) – and they also consume favor – there is not much point in building them purely for attacking.
Horsemen
Type of attack: Blunt
Attack/FS: 13.9 (by Sea) or 18.3 (by Land)
Cost/Attack: 17.9 (by Sea) or 13.1 (by Land)
Horsemen have lower attack/FS than Slingers and
are more expensive. It’s not my favorite option when attacking enemy player, unless I am hitting defense with little Blunt defense. In most of the
situations Slingers will be simply cheaper and faster to rebuild than Horsemen.
However if costs are not an issue for you then Horsemen can be often a very effective offensive force. Regular (non-mythical) units specializing in blunt defense (i.e. Hoplites or Chariots) have the lowest Defense/FS among all defensive units. Even if your opponent chooses to build a defense of 300 hoplites, you will be able to counter it with 100 horsemen (that is the same 300 FS). If you were building slingers you would find it much more difficult to deal with a defense of pure Swordsmen. For more details please check my tables here (especially the one at the bottom).
Stronger (more effective) blunt attackers are Harpies, simply because they do not need ships to be carried over. Therefore you can build more Harpies, using FS that did not go into transport ships and escort (Light Ships). Harpy has 19 attack/FS.
Horsemen are fast and can carry a lot of loot so it’s a good farming unit which I send to farm other players who have already been cleared by my offensive forces.
Stronger (more effective) blunt attackers are Harpies, simply because they do not need ships to be carried over. Therefore you can build more Harpies, using FS that did not go into transport ships and escort (Light Ships). Harpy has 19 attack/FS.
Horsemen are fast and can carry a lot of loot so it’s a good farming unit which I send to farm other players who have already been cleared by my offensive forces.
Offensive/Defensive Units
Hoplites
Type of attack: Sharp
Attack/FS: 12.2 (by Sea) or 16 (by Land)
Total defense/FS: 9.4 (by Sea) or 12.3 (by Land)
Cost/Attack: 19.6 (by Sea) or 14.1 (by Land)
Cost/Total defense: 25.4 (by Sea) or 18.2 (by Land)
Hoplites are not as strong in attack as Slingers or Horsemen which doesn't make them perfect attack forces.
They also don't have the best defensive stats. All non-mythical sharp attackers are balanced units, so your
sharp attacking army will contribute a lot to your defense as well.
Offense
They can be used in attack when a player doesn't
have any Archers (sharp defense) in his city.
Archers are very popular defensive units and
they are very effective sharp defense. So if you are going for a chariot/hoplite offense, make sure your
opponent is not stockpiling archers: this will make your attack
extremely ineffective, even if you win your losses both in resource and
in farm space will be a lot higher.If you decide to focus on sharp attack, you have a choice between hoplites and chariots. Hoplites have a slightly higher Attack/FS, they are cheaper resource wise, the associated research requires less points and is accessible earlier in the academy. They are slow and can’t carry much resources, so not good for farming. Chariots have the bonus of speed and better loot, which makes so much more effective at farming, though still much worse than horses.
Defense
Hoplites are essential for balanced defense if you want
to be protected against blunt attacks. You can start producing them early, before Chariots. They have strong
blunt defense, medium sharp def (half of what Archers have but more than
Swordsmen) and bad range def.
Their strongest point is their ability to
perform Conquest missions (so are more useful in a Conquest World). Their attack and defense values are not the highest
but they can perform both tasks at the same time. Their weaker stats are price for
their universality. When you send a Colony Ship it might happen that a defender
will do a very quick dodge with his land units or plan an attack which will hit
your CS forces before your support arrives. In that case you are defending
the town and only defensive stats count. Some could think that sending Swordsmen
and Archers would be a good idea but it is not. Archers and Swordsmen are
terrible in attack, so if the defender decides to not dodge but take the hit,
then all your forces will be wiped easily. For those reasons hoplites and chariots
are the best regular units to send with your Colony Ship.
I must admit I have sent a few Archers with my CS but
most of my forces were made of hoplites and chariots. I don't believe anyone
will stick to rigid numbers but just to give you a few ideas of units that you can send with your CS:
a) Strong attack and blunt defense but weaker sharp
and range defense - 400 hops+150 chariot
(attack: 14800 defense: 18600
blunt / 7200 sharp / 11200 range)
b) Weaker attack and blunt defense but strong sharp
and range defense - 250 Archers+188 chariots
(attack: 12528 defense: 15788 blunt /
9258 sharp / 13528 range)
The weaker the attack the more units you will lose
during it so will have fewer units left for defending, which makes option b
not such a great idea. If the defender dodges though, then option b is better
than a. I personally don't stick to any numbers - I mix Hoplites with Chariots and add some Archers for a quick conquest wave.
There are two mythical units with sharp attack, and both are excellent attackers. Manticore has the highest sharp Attack/FS (and attack in general) and Medusa has the 2nd best, only a little lower. Also Manticores can fly, so the same bonus as for harpies applies to them.
There are two mythical units with sharp attack, and both are excellent attackers. Manticore has the highest sharp Attack/FS (and attack in general) and Medusa has the 2nd best, only a little lower. Also Manticores can fly, so the same bonus as for harpies applies to them.
Chariots
Type of attack: Sharp
Attack/FS: 10.6 (by Sea) or 14 (by Land)
Total defense/FS: 9.4 (by Sea) or 12.3 (by Land)
Cost/Attack: 23.5 (by Sea) or 17.1 (by Land)
Cost/Total defense: 26.6 (by Sea) or 19.5 (by Land)
The same story as with hoplites but they have different defensive stats. Basically blunt defense is the same, sharp defense is much
worse and range defense much better.
Their blunt defense is bit better than hoplites (19
not 18) but it doesn't make much difference.
Sharp defense is awful equal 4 (hoplites have 12).
Range defense is much better equal 14 (hoplites have 7)
So we can see that chariots and hoplites mixed together will
add a lot of blunt defense and acceptable sharp and range defense.
If you haven't noticed yet chariots have half of the Swordsman range defense and
hoplites have half of the Archers sharp defense (which are their dominant stats).
Chariots are bit weaker in attack than hoplites (14
instead of 16).
Chariots
and hoplites are expensive units and hoplites cost lot of silver
leaving plenty of wood in the city producing them. They are not perfect
for attacking but good as a CS escort.
Defensive Units
The best possible defense are defensive units behind high wall.
The highest overall defense value among regular (non-mythical) units has Swordsman but Archer is not far behind. These 2 units are bread and butter of every strong defense.
However the best defensive units in the game are Pegasus, then Cerberus and Medusa.
Pegasi with Centaurs (or Archers) are perfect combo (also note, that you can mix 2 mythical units in the same place as it is the same god). Just add a few swordsmen for extra distance defense and put them behind 25 lvl wall.
If you would like to learn more how to build a perfect land defense then please see my other guide which you can find here.
Swordsman
Strongest defense value: Range
Total defense/FS: 13.2 (by Sea) or 17.3 (by Land)
Cost/Total defense: 15.5 (by Sea) or 10.4 (by Land)
Total defense/FS: 13.2 (by Sea) or 17.3 (by Land)
Cost/Total defense: 15.5 (by Sea) or 10.4 (by Land)
Swordsman is a fundamental defensive unit with the
highest among regular units Total Defense. Swordsmen with Archers make
foundation of your land defensive forces. If you can’t afford hoplites make
more of Swordsmen instead. Never send them to attack anything, not even to farm
an empty city as even without walls you will have casualties.
Archer
Strongest defense value: Sharp
Total defensive/FS: 10.9 (by Sea) or 14.3 (by Land)
Cost/Total defense: 19.8 (by Sea) or 13.6 (by Land)
Total defensive/FS: 10.9 (by Sea) or 14.3 (by Land)
Cost/Total defense: 19.8 (by Sea) or 13.6 (by Land)
Second the most important defensive unit. Not much
to say except that it’s one of the strongest sharp defenses in the game (2nd
highest). You can send your Archers
when farming other player cities (not attacking them, but farming after
you've killed their army) because they can carry a lot of loot. Please
remember that Archers are defensive units, which can be used to carry
out resources from an enemy city when its empty and should not be used
to kill enemy units.
Never attack another player’s city with Swordsmen or Archers.
Never attack another player’s city with Swordsmen or Archers.
If you have any question or would like to add anything, please leave your comment
cheers :)
cheers :)
is it ok to have a chariot nuke? or are they mainly used for defense?
ReplyDeleteI do not think Chariots are good for attacking in general. They are good when you send them with CS in a Conquest world, so they hold siege until stronger defensive units arrive but for purely offensive missions I would not rely on them.
ReplyDeleteCheck tables comparing attack per Farm Space of different units and you will see yourself:
http://grepolis-pro.blogspot.co.uk/2008/05/offensive-units-comparison.html
Also check how expensive chariots are:
http://grepolis-pro.blogspot.co.uk/2008/05/units-efficiency-costs-comparison.html
If you really want to send a sharp nuke use Hoplites, Medusae or Manticores. Mantis are the strongest and the cheapest if you don't count Favour Points.